University of Amsterdam
Informatics Institute
Christof Monz

Home

Projects

Research

Publications

Teaching

Activities

Software

Other Stuff

Bio

So, you want to do a PhD...


Home
Before you enroll
In the beginning of your PhD
Knee-deep into your PhD
So near and yet so far
Done!




In the beginning of your PhD (oh, early days...)

So, you've chosen a supervisor and a topic for your PhD. Now that you're about to embark on this journey it's important to clarify a number of things that will help you make sure you know where you're going.
  • Discuss with your supervisor what is expected from your PhD:
    • What are the main expected outcomes of your PhD? Together with your supervisor put together a plan for the rest of your PhD that states exactly what is expected when. Learn to stick to these deadlines. Obviously there will be situations where you miss deadlines, but having a clear plan for your PhD gives you a better picture of how far away you are from your 'ideal' PhD. If you have to revise parts of your plan, do so carefully and always after discussing it with your supervisor.
    • What are the key conferences and journals you are supposed to publish in? This differs from area to area and your supervisor can provide you with this information.
    • How many key publications are enough? Again this differs from area to area. As a rule of thumb: 2-3 conference publications, one or two of which are extended into journal publications. These publications are essential. They feed directly into your PhD thesis later on, you get peer feedback on them giving you a good idea how your work compares to the state of the art in your area, and last but not least, they keep your supervisor happy.
    • Agree on a slot for regular meetings with your supervisor. These meetings can be held weekly or bi-weekly. Personally, I prefer to meet with my students weekly, but in any case, make sure you meet with your supervisor frequently and on a regular basis. The purpose of these meetings is to discuss your progress, new ideas, technical problems, etc.

  • Estimate your financial situation. PhD stipends or salaries are certainly not known to be generous anywhere in the world. Normally, it should be enough though to allow you an okay standard of living. If you don't get a stipend or have an expensive fine wine habit to feed, and you don't come from a well-heeled family, you probably have to earn some money on the side. Most PhD students do so by working as teaching assistants (TAs). Although TA-ing in moderate amounts does not interfere too much with your PhD, don't overdo it as this can hinder progress with your PhD. Start with as little TA-ing as you think will give you enough money to survive. Remember, a PhD is a full-time job, and your supervisor will expect you to treat it like one. Despite its flexible working hours, you should expect to put in at least 8 hours a day.

  • Read, read, and read. It's important that you get a good understanding of the research problems in your area early on. You don't want to find out half-way through your PhD that somebody else has already tried out your idea. Your supervisor should of course know the area very well, but unlike what some of them like you to believe, they are not infallible. I initially point my students to the most important and relevant publications in the area which are a good starting point for their own literature research. We then discuss regularly the other approaches, and how the PhD student's approach differs from them, either in one-on-one meetings or in our reading group. In addition to just reading it's also a good idea to write short summaries of the most relevant papers. All PhD theses I'm aware of include a literature review or background chapter, which should be written early in your PhD. Of course, you have to revise this chapter later on, as the world around you does not stand still, but having a first version of a literature review early on is yet another thing you can tick off on your to-do list. Do not only read papers but also one or two PhD theses by others. You can ask your supervisor which ones he or she recommends. You might not understand all the details at this point, but you get an idea what a good PhD thesis looks like.

  • Try to write your first paper within a year after you've picked your supervisor and PhD topic. Since conference submission deadlines tend to be not during the summer, this could mean that you have to submit your paper before (preferably) or after the first year has passed. Getting your first publication out in time is important for two reasons: Firstly, your first publication will fill you with immense pride (and rightly so) and it's a huge motivational boost. Secondly, time is limited and getting things done in time will prevent you from being stressed later on.

  • Talk to the other PhD students in your group, especially the ones that are a few years ahead. They have learned many of the lessons the hard way. Talking to them can help you avoid falling into the same traps. They also know the, lets say, peculiarities of your supervisor which will help you convince that it's actually your supervisor who's the weird one and not you. Talking regularly to your fellow PhD students about your research also allows you to bat around crazy ideas. Although these discussions should not replace the discussions with your supervisor during your regular meetings they are an important addition.

  • Use any opportunity to present your work at group seminars. This is a friendly environment where you can present your ideas, your progress, and your results and get valuable feedback from a wider audience, including colleagues of your supervisor, you normally don't talk to on a regular basis. Plus, practicing talks is important. These dry-runs will improve your presentation skills considerably.

Next: Knee-deep into your PhD (in other words: 'being stuck!')